Pueblo's newest bakery and coffee shop, dubbed "Grumpy's Cafe," is a place where crabby old men are welcome to gather, sip coffee, and munch on giant cinnamon rolls as they mull over the world's woes.

Caroline Bell co-founded Café Grumpy in 2005 in the Brooklyn, N.Y., neighborhood of Greenpoint, partly because she was an office worker who was having trouble finding a decent cup of coffee nearby. “I ...